Monday, December 15, 2014

Blog Post #20 TEWWG Socratic Seminar Part 2

Task #1
Janie sees maturity
Janie seeks reason
Janie finds meaning

Task #2
TEWWG is a novel about the statures of growth. As part of the growing experience, acceptance is a needed virtue. The idea of growth also parallels with the other texts that we have read from the beginning of the school year. First of all, the novel parallels with the poem “The Poison Tree” by William Blake. “And it grew both day and night. Till it bore an apple bright.”(Blake) is a line that shows in which the growing process is a slow and steady ideal. However, the novel also manages to say that the growing process can bring in meanings which are bright as that of the apple. Therefore, it can be seen that life is a system in which an ideal is searched for. For a more darker connection, “The Black Walnut Tree,” by Mary Oliver along with the TEWWG novel shows that the power of growing involves very darker times. For example, Janie underwent many dark times with Logan Killicks and Jody Stark, before she found the perfect soul mate, Tea Cake. The poem itself only takes a small section of the growth process where the struggling occurs, which is battle against the mortgage. In addition, the novel and poem both connect at an instant in which there are sacrifices. The main narrator of the poem is in the debate of sacrificing the Black Walnut Tree, while Janie, in some instances, sacrificed her personal independence for the sake of love. As said by Janie “she saw her life like a great tree in life with things suffered, things enjoyed, things done and undone,” (Hurston 8).
Task #3
Both the play of Hamlet and the novel of TEWWG, parallel with the idea of destruction caused by the emotion of love. Janie and Ophelia both care the tender and innocent nature of being submissive. As Hamlet was to Ophelia, Janie had her two husbands similar to the characteristics of Hamlet. They wanted Janie to abide by their rules, which Janie did without question. In addition, they would psychologically abuse her similar to how Hamlet did to Ophelia. Hamlet says “get thee to the nunnery,” (3.1.119), which is similar to the idea of how Jody Starks insults Janie with his speech about her social stature and age. There comes a time in which these characters start to fight back directly or indirectly. Their moves trigger the male to step down from his domination. It comes to the scenario in which the male must now depend on the female. In Hamlet, the death of Ophelia strikes him emotionally, in which he starts to confess about his love for her. He sees that his love for Ophelia to be more emotionally striking than of the death of his father. In Janie’s instance, she talks back at Jody Starks which immediately triggers a sense of insecurity within the male. Janie says to her husband, “you have tuh have power tuh free things and dat makes you lak un king uh something ,” (Hurston 57). This immediately causes for the male to step down and ask for mercy. Therefore, both the novel and play talk about the destruction of the male when he falls into the contraption of love.   


Tuesday, December 2, 2014

Blog Post #18 Hamlet Final Essay